We use essential storage to keep your cart and checkout working. With your permission, optional analytics helps us improve the website; it is not switched on yet, so nothing optional loads today. You can reject optional cookies and change your choice at any time.
Your browser sends a Global Privacy Control signal, so optional cookies stay off.
A few times a year we chalk up something special: a dessert pizza for Valentine's Day, a slab for Easter and Thanksgiving, cookie boxes for Canada Day, Halloween and the holidays, and the dishes named for our own mom and dad on Mother's Day and Father's Day. Each one stays on the menu for its window, from the same kitchen and scratch pantry as everything else.
OrderAt least three days aheadPick your date at checkout (Toronto time)
Minimum$100 before tax and deliveryMix dishes from any menu to reach it
The holiday calendar
Midnight Cocoa Cookie Box for Halloween: pickup or delivery October 29 to 31, 2026. Pre-orders open October 8, 2026.
Spumoni Christmas Cookie Box for Christmas and New Year: pickup or delivery December 20 to 24, 2026. Pre-orders open November 29, 2026.
Spumoni Christmas Cookie Box for Christmas and New Year: pickup or delivery December 29 to 31, 2026. Pre-orders open December 8, 2026.
Best eaten hot on arrival. To bring it back: oven at 475°F with a baking sheet inside for 15 minutes, slices straight onto the hot sheet for 4 to 6 minutes, until the cheese bubbles and the middle is piping hot (165°F); or a dry heavy frying pan on medium heat, lid on, 3 to 4 minutes. No microwave. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours and eat within 2 days. Keep the ricotta pot in the fridge until you sit down; drizzle the honey over the slices and dip the crusts in the ricotta.
10 inch$20.00
14 inch$29.00
18 inch$48.00
Papa Edgar's Father's Day Table
From $54.00
For Edgar, the owner's dad.
Papa Edgar's Salmon Oreganata for Father's Day, with lemon rosemary potatoes, asparagus and lemon garlic butter to pour at the table.
Family table
Father's Day: pickup or delivery June 18 to 20, 2027. Pre-orders open May 28, 2027.
Contains: Wheat, Barley, Milk, Fish. May contain: Peanuts, Tree nuts (almond), Soy.
Arrives hot: warm the lemon garlic butter pot (lid off) 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, pour it over the salmon, then shower on the crumb and squeeze the lemon. From the fridge (within 2 days): salmon, potatoes and asparagus covered at 300°F for 12 to 15 minutes to 165°F, then the butter and crumb. Keep the cookies at room temperature, away from the hot food.
For two (2 plates)$54.00
For four (4 plates)$80.00
Add one if you like
Add 6 Espresso Toffee Bodega cookies+ $13.00Adds: Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy. May contain: Tree nuts (almond, hazelnut).
Strawberry Maple Shortcake Cookie Box
From $32.00
Canada Day lands in Ontario strawberry season, so the jammy centres are cooked from that week's berries, under a reduced maple glaze.
Vegetarian
Canada Day: pickup or delivery June 30 to July 1, 2027. Pre-orders open June 9, 2027.
Contains: Wheat, Milk, Egg.
Travels at room temperature.Ingredients and serving
Keep the cake covered at room temperature up to 2 days, then in the fridge. Warm squares 8 minutes at 300°F. Keep the caramel in the fridge; stand the pot in hot tap water 5 minutes to pour it warm.
12 x 12 inch pan, 2 inch deep$63.00
Midnight Cocoa Cookie Box
From $32.00
A brown-butter cookie so dark with cocoa it bakes near black, pools of dark and milk chocolate and an orange glaze spider web. No bought candy.
Vegetarian
Halloween: pickup or delivery October 29 to 31, 2026. Pre-orders open October 8, 2026.
Halloween: pickup or delivery October 29 to 31, 2027. Pre-orders open October 8, 2027.
Contains: Wheat, Milk, Egg, Soy. May contain: Tree nuts (almond, hazelnut).
Travels at room temperature.Ingredients and serving
Eat within 3 days, box closed at room temperature. For a just-baked cookie: 5 minutes on a tray in a 300°F oven, rest 5 minutes.
Half dozen (6 cookies)$32.00
Full dozen (12 cookies)$60.00
Spumoni Christmas Cookie Box
From $32.00
The spumoni of the old Brooklyn pizza gardens in one cookie: pistachio, sour cherry and dark chocolate under a white glaze.
House signature
Vegetarian
Contains nuts
Christmas and New Year: pickup or delivery December 20 to 24, 2026. Pre-orders open November 29, 2026.
Christmas and New Year: pickup or delivery December 29 to 31, 2026. Pre-orders open December 8, 2026.
Contains: Wheat, Milk, Egg, Tree nuts (pistachio), Soy. May contain: Peanuts, Tree nuts (almond, Brazil nut, cashew, hazelnut, macadamia, pecan, pine nut, walnut), Sulphites.
Travels at room temperature.Ingredients and serving
Eat within 3 days, box closed at room temperature. For a just-baked cookie: 5 minutes on a tray in a 300°F oven, rest 5 minutes.
Half dozen (6 cookies)$32.00
Full dozen (12 cookies)$66.00
What the icons mean
House signature
One of the dishes Sear & Shred is built on.
Family table
A dish from the owner's family table.
Vegetarian
No meat or fish in the dish as listed. An add-on can change that, so read its label.
Contains nuts
At least one size or option of this dish contains peanuts or tree nuts.
Spicy
This dish carries heat. The card says how much, in words and in chillies.
Heat
Mild: a gentle warmth; Medium heat; Hot. A dish with no heat line has none.
Our kitchen handles Wheat, Barley, Oats, Milk, Egg, Fish, Tree nuts (pistachio), Soy, Mustard and Sulphites. Some dishes may also contain Peanuts and Tree nuts (almond, cashew, hazelnut, walnut, Brazil nut, macadamia, pecan, pine nut): each dish's card says which. We cannot promise any dish is free of them.
Why three days
Nothing here is waiting on a shelf. Once the orders are in, we buy fresh for them, and our dough begins: an overnight starter with a little whole wheat, then strong unbleached bread flour, then 48 hours resting in the cold before it warms, rises and goes into the oven on your pickup day. Sauces are simmered and the meats roasted in the days between. Three days, start to finish, and you can taste every one of them.
Pickup and delivery dates are at least 3 days after the day you order (weekends and holidays count). Orders close at 10 AM on Saturday for Monday to Wednesday dates and at 10 AM on Tuesday for Thursday to Sunday dates (Toronto time), so the first open date can be later. $100 minimum before tax and delivery. Pickup and delivery run from 8 AM to 8 PM (Toronto time).
Hungry yet?
BUILD YOUR ORDER
Mix dishes from any menu. $100 minimum before tax and delivery. Pickup or delivery.